Caricature

By Cicero | Related entries in Cartoons, The World

It has become common to think of ‘The West’, as depicted by Cox and Forkum, as clueless — groping at any hope for peace with its enemies. Cox and Forkum’s ‘The West’ character looks like a middle-aged geek with thick glasses, tie and soft belly, comfortable on his knees; he’s an apparachik of the easy life, submissive before any appeasement that guarantees another meal.

Of course, this is a cartoon. A cartoon makes caricatures of people and things in simple, pointed exaggerations. But it is still instructive in terms of how we see ourselves.

It’s been a while since I had a television, but I remember a phase of advertising that I called ‘Dumb Guy.’ It’s probably still somewhat prevalent. Dumb Guy is the fortyish-year old upper-middle class American male, depicted as an amiable, soft-headed, impressionable dunce. His beautiful wife and kids are always smarter than he is. And yet, there he stands in his palatial suburban house with twin SUVs, unable to solve a simple domestic challenge. He’s easily coerced and happily led to a simple answer from the sponsor.

I found the Dumb Guy ads to be particularly condescending. Impossibly, Dumb Guy is able to amass great wealth in spite of his idiocy. Apparently, an army of milquetoasts wound at the top of the global food chain — not innovative, proud, courageous, manipulative or shrewd individualists. What does Dumb Guy do for a living? Sell balloons to puppies? How could this simpleton get this far in life and represent our culture? Is this how we see ourselves — as a bunch of soft-hearted simpletons who inexplicably became the spineless backbone of our culture?

I worry that Dumb Guy is our self image — being that of the West, or America. But our self image as American-consumerist-Bible-thumping Dumb Guys, or European-socialist-teat-nursing-appeaser Dumb Guys doesn’t really matter. Either way, we’re just dumb. Isn’t Cox and Forkum’s ‘West’ hopelessly condescending, and inaccurate?

‘Dumb Guy West’ also has a huge nuclear arsenal in his back pocket. He is complex, and not merely a caricature of a Pavlovian idiot who is led towards carrots, away from sticks. ‘The West’ is fearsome — for its sheer power to create and destroy at huge levels of magnitude. The West is still fearsome.

Boiling ‘The West’ down to a single caricature is telling. When has the West ever been one? Michael Totten says that it never was on the same page. Why should we all be on the same page now? Is a common threat really a uniter? I doubt it. Common threats more often expose rifts that are normally glossed over. That seems to be the case now.

The Iranian nuclear crisis challenges the idea that ‘The West’ can act together as one. Political realities are what they are — Europeans and Americans wound up where they are for different reasons. Expecting a concerted effort against Iran is a fantasy. Presuming that we should act as one in this crisis is a fantasy too. It sounds nice — I just don’t think it’s ultimately workable.

Cox and Forkum’s cartoon would be more accurate if ‘The West’ was a pack of animals that Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was trying to ride atop of, all at once — not just one Dumb Guy. Some of the animals might be bears, others sheep, monkeys and birds, running in all directions. It’s silly to boil the West down into a single meek caricature while portraying Ahmadinejad as the master manipulator. In spite of Western divisions on the challenges Ahmadinejad poses, I hardly see him as being in control, riding the West like a Persian cowboy. He’s on very thin ice.

These are dangerous times, for a lot of reasons. Boiling the present historical fulcrum down to caricatures is a job best left to cartoonists. Hopefully, we’re not the dumb guys that just buy into it.


This entry was posted on Wednesday, August 23rd, 2006 and is filed under Cartoons, The World. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

4 Responses to “Caricature”

  1. Jack Whelan Says:

    I agree; it’s not the West that is “dumb guy”, it’s this administration and its continued supporters. Label the carrot “oil,” and the missile “terrorist hysteria,” and you have a pretty good picture of the thinking and motivation of this slice of the complex Western pie, a slice which unfortunately has enormous power right now. It has been played by the Iranians, is being played, and it will continue to be played. This clueless slice is in so far over its head it still thinks its in control of the situation. It would be facetious if so many people weren’t getting hurt.

  2. Walrus Says:

    I’m glad I’m not the only one who finds the Dumb Guy ads (and TV shows!) obnoxious. They go hand in hand with all the beer commercials who portray frat boy stupidity as a goal to aspire to. As a wife of an intelligent man and the mother of four boys I get awfully tired of this form of sexism committed by men against themselves. (Sorry, not touching the geopolitical aspects today.)

  3. Brian in MA Says:

    Jack Whelan:

    Funny, I see the Dumb Guy as more the UN looking at “Bribes and Appeasement through Diplomacy” as a carrot and “Islamo-Fascism” as the missile. The UN is a useless leech on American society eating up tax dollars in NYC. Their resolutions are paper tigers and they, being unaffected by anything until their countries are attacked, refuse to look reality in the face. Why do you think London is a generally stronger ally than the others in Europe? Because they got attacked and refused to buckle down and stop the Islamo-Fascist wave. France and Germany meanwhile, have played the odds and hoped that if they just appease appease appease, they might be spared from annihalation or sharia law.

    And if we were really after Oil Jack, WHY would we go to Iraq and disrupt the flow by taking out the guy in charge? If we just wanted the Oil Carrot, we’d be slick like the noble UN and engage in Oil for Food with the merry dictator. I find it interesting that everyone wants to call Bush the “dumb guy”, when he is the ONLY one sans Isreal, whose very existence lies in the balance, doing anything proactive about Terrorism.

  4. Jimmy the Dhimmi Says:

    Don’t forget, Jack, that Iraq’s oil industry is now more socialist than Venezuela’s under your freind Hugo Chavez. The democratically elected Iraqi parliament has done that.

Leave a Reply


NOTE TO COMMENTERS:


You must ALWAYS fill in the two word CAPTCHA below to submit a comment. And if this is your first time commenting on Donklephant, it will be held in a moderation queue for approval. Please don't resubmit the same comment a couple times. We'll get around to moderating it soon enough.


Also, sometimes even if you've commented before, it may still get placed in a moderation queue and/or sent to the spam folder. If it's just in moderation queue, it'll be published, but it may be deleted if it lands in the spam folder. My apologies if this happens but there are some keywords that push it into the spam folder.


One last note, we will not tolerate comments that disparage people based on age, sex, handicap, race, color, sexual orientation, national origin or ancestry. We reserve the right to delete these comments and ban the people who make them from ever commenting here again.


Thanks for understanding and have a pleasurable commenting experience.


Related Posts: