A Few Words on Hate and Politics
By Alan Stewart Carl | Related entries in Blogging, Conservatism, General Politics, Liberalism, Partisan NonsenseNothing turns me off like partisan anger. I know a lot of people like to get wrapped up in the false fury propagated by certain partisans, but I try to keep my irrational outbursts focused primarily on my beloved Dallas Cowboys. I don’t really understand those who feel the need to bring the gladiatorial spirit to the realm of politics.
Perhaps my temperament is due to the simple fact that I grew up a Democrat in a profoundly Republican town. Rage was useless. The only hope I had of joining a political discussion was to speak reasonably and acknowledge the intelligence of my opponents. When such niceties were impossible, I learned to hold my tongue.
During the Bill Clinton years, I was profoundly turned off by the unceasing Republican attacks on Clinton, particularly the most scurrilous rumors spread by talk-show hosts. I came to believe that Republicans were uniquely gifted at proliferating hate. My response was to not vote for a single Republican between 1994 and 2001.
Then something radically changed my view.
I moved to Washington, DC and came face-to-face with the underbelly of my own “side.†During the first four years of George W. Bush’s presidency, I saw a level of hate and anger that shocked me. From enraged marches to hateful signs hung on lampposts to casually spewed vitriol at cocktail parties, I discovered that unhinged partisanship and blind hate is not a disease congenital to only one party or one political leaning.
By late 2004, I had become an independent for a variety of reasons, not least of which was my inability to continue tolerating the hatefulness on my own side. Then I joined the blogosphere in early 2005 as one of the few “centrist†voices and encountered a noise-storm of hate that made my personal DC experiences seem like a tea party. Much of the animosity emanated from the left in a desperate and unyielding attempt to portray Bush and his Republican colleagues as the largest bunch of crooks, thieves and murderers to ever lead a nation. I quickly learned that going against leftwing orthodoxy was the surest way to get my comments stuffed with hate-you-grams.
Interestingly (predictably, even), that intense level of vitriol quieted some after the Democrats took the House and Senate in 2006. It even quieted in the lead-up to that election as the usual instigators busied themselves with the very real possibility of victory. Now that Barack Obama looks poised to take the White House and complete the total Democratic takeover of the U.S. Government, I have a hard time finding examples of truly hateful lefty speech, except here-and-there in comment sections and at the fringes where even Obama is considered part of the American imperialist conspiracy.
Suddenly, when it comes to partisan anger, we’re talking about unhinged John McCain supporters. I’d like to think that this rightwing nuttiness is just a temporary loss of bearings due to the election. But I’m afraid the modern political landscape is too ripe with fervent partisanship to avoid the kind of impotent rage from the right that we so recently saw from the left. In my most cynical moments, I’m afraid the shouts at McCain rallies are just the tip of the iceberg.
But maybe I’m wrong. Maybe we’re reaching a fatigue moment where the over-emotionalism of the last decade-and-a-half will quiet down. Maybe with an economic slump and a better-executed war abroad, we can exile the hate to the fringes where it belongs. And maybe Obama will surprise the hell out of me and actually be a uniter. Whatever happens, I’ll still be one of those annoying independents telling people to simmer down and trying not to get upset every time I’m accused of false equivalencies. Because, the thing is, hate is destructive, whether it’s just a little bit of hate or a whole lot of hate. And if you’re not speaking against it, you’re tolerating it.
Anyway, that’s what’s been on my mind today.
This entry was posted on Tuesday, October 14th, 2008 and is filed under Blogging, Conservatism, General Politics, Liberalism, Partisan Nonsense. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.











October 14th, 2008 at 5:19 pm
When you feel that the supposedly unbiased media is overtly pushing a candidate, you have a right to be angry.
Can we rename the New York Times to be Pravda West?
October 14th, 2008 at 5:54 pm
I hate to say it, but I have visions of the conflict between Sunni and Shiite muslims soon being the blueprint for the conflict between Democrats and Republicans. People are losing their minds! Between the numerous nasty comments at McCain rallies and the cult-like Obamessiah following, I predict a death soon. I’ve already seen violence in the form of slashed tires because someone had a certain bumper sticker. I’ve heard people say with pride that they won’t stop to help someone on the side of the road if they are displaying a certain political bumper sticker. It’s disgusting!
October 14th, 2008 at 6:48 pm
I should have known.
Steeler fan.
October 14th, 2008 at 9:30 pm
“unyielding attempt to portray Bush and his Republican colleagues as the largest bunch of crooks, thieves and murderers to ever lead a nation”
… and this isn’t true? Maybe not “a” nation, but quite possibly our nation.
October 14th, 2008 at 10:31 pm
Chris, you obviously have never lived under a totalitarian regime that rapes its country of its rights and resources. Check back with us when you do.
October 15th, 2008 at 3:41 am
Ah, yes, so we seem to be in a seperate-but-similar situation.
I’ve been a Republican in one of the “bluest” states in the nation for as long as I have been politically aware. Part of it was spending my politically formative years in that very environment of liberal rage. Partly to rebel against such people and after much thinking, I have supported the center-right wing of the GOP since then. This was rather difficult at times in college. I studied international relations and was asked time and again how I could be studying that subject and remain even a centrist and not become a die-hard liberal. Even my own professors asked me this. I really do see a certain sense of liberal intellectual elitism on college campuses, especially among professors. I can say this because I worked with the Political Science department in depth at my university and saw it with my own eyes.
Now I still do not like the attitude of liberals in the US – they’re either still raging, or messianic Obamabots, or so smug it’s sickening. Many really do perceive conservatives as either without a brain or heart, or as pure evil, without a soul.
However, in the past two years, I have seen that rage that you see building on the right as well. They’re so angry, they’re making claims that even they know are false in order to stoke even more anger. It’s bringing out the dark side of my own party, another thing I saw in college; such people actually had a registered club on campus. I especially think that John McCain’s choice of Sarah Palin as his running mate exacerbated the problem. If such an environment continues, someone really will get hurt, and although I want to remain with the GOP, I really do not want to be associated with the right-wing anger. I think either John McCain or Barack Obama could be a good president. If one looks at either of their policies, there’s potential. So, please, PLEASE, let’s stop the anger on BOTH sides and work together to put this country back together!